lohud.com

Sponsored by:

Opinion Exchange

A conversation with the Editorial Board

Abstinence-only sex ed success, really

Nancy Cutler
February
2

One study has shown that an abstinence-only sex education curriculum can be effective for young teens, according to the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine.

That finding has been called a “game changer” by Bill Albert, chief program officer at the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy, a nonprofit, nonpartisan group based in Washington.

No matter where you fall on the sex-ed spectrum, this should be seen as good news. Why? Because we can look at the specifics of this program and that can help figure out what works when teaching kids how to remain healthy. Considering that teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases have increased, according to recently released data, all information about sex ed efficacy should get our attention.

What’s the big deal? Well, under the Bush administration, the funding floodgates were opened to programs that were what’s called “abstinence only” rather than programs called “abstinence based” and/or “comprehensive sex ed.” The traditional abstinence only programs, which often took a moral tilt on the topic and were religion-oriented, were consistently found lacking in results by myriad studies. Now, we have one program that has shown some success. The Obama administration has said it would only fund sex-ed programs that could show effectiveness, which left most abstinence-only programs in the cold. The game changes again.

This abstinence-only program was different than many, in that it discussed delaying sexual activity, but didn’t specify that sex was only for marriage. Also, the curriculum was devoid of religion. The reasons for abstinence focused on avoiding pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases, rather than a moral message.

The study showed that the program could reduce sexual activity by nearly a third in 12- and 13-year-olds compared with students who received no sex education. But the window wasn’t so wide when compared to children who took part in safe-sex classes and comprehensive sex ed (which states abstinence is the most effective way to avoid pregnancy and STDs but includes safe sex lessons). In those programs, for this particular study, sexual activity was reduced by about 20 percent and a 40 percent reduction in multiple partners.

The study, though, didn’t demonstrate any increased use of condoms or other birth control when the students did have sex, no matter which curriculum was used. That puts kids who are sexually active at risk of pregnancy and disease.

There’s been lots of hard questions about this study. For example, will such education work for older children, or kids from other demographic backgrounds? That is why the examinations need to continue. But this is interesting data that needs to grab our attention. Kids need facts, and it’s a fact that abstinence is a 100 percent proven form of birth control. It’s also a fact that many teens will not remain abstinent—putting them at risk for STDs and pregnancy, especially if they lack information on how to prevent both. That’s where the need for education beyond abstinence (and the controversy) comes in. (Often called abstinence-based or abstinence-plus sex ed.)

The point is to keep kids healthy. This study provides another avenue. Let’s keep studying, and keep talking to our kids. Because, a study of common sense shows, for healthy kids with healthy attitudes, children  need to hear about “the big stuff” like sex ed from their parents, not just a classroom talk.

To read about the study, check out this L.A. Times article.

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Tuesday, February 2nd, 2010 at 1:28 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

A new Assemblyman … and a new chairman

Herb Pinder
February
1

Candidates vying for the vacated 89th District state Assembly seat — Republican Robert Castelli and Democrat Peter Harckham — appear in a LIVE Editorial Spotlight interview at 2:15 p.m. Wednesday; to watch or submit questions click here. The seat was vacated when Adam Bradley became White Plains mayor.

Also this week: Ken Jenkins, new chairman of the Westcheser Board of Legislators, meets with the Editorial Board LIVE at 1 p.m. Thursday. For both interviews. Go to www.lohud.com/editorialspotlight.

Posted by Herb Pinder on Monday, February 1st, 2010 at 5:39 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

Advertisement

Graduating from addiction

Nancy Cutler
January
28

Today, 21 people graduated from Rockland County Drug Court , the largest class in the program’s 12-year history. Drug Courts aren’t new, and in fact, have grown more common around the country.

But this graduating class also included eight who had been convicted of felony driving while intoxicated. That’s a new path for Drug Courts, and Rockland is among the few to allow DWI violators to enter the program. The speaker in today’s ceremony was Sheila Abrams of Westchester MADD. Rockland County Court Judge Charles Apotheker (who runs the Drug Court program) met her during a Journal News/LoHud.com Editorial Spotlight panel discussion about drunken driving. Abrams’ two children were killed in a drunken driving crash. Abrams said it’s hard for many to understand why treatment is so important, and why she supports treatment over incarceration. “The victim’s first thought is, I wnt them to go to jail, they destroyed my family, I want them to go to jail,” she said, reflecting on her own pain and anger. But, Abrams said, the underlying issue of addiction won’t be addressed there. And that is the hard work, and the important work. “What you did today was historic,” she said of the Drug Court graduates.

Rockland District Attorney Thomas Zugibe also addressed the graduates and the near 100 supporters there to witness their accomplishment. “People say, ‘don’t you think you’re going soft on crime,’” he said of his support of Drug Court programs. “My job is to keep the public safe,” the DA said, “and there’s no better example of a prevention program than Drug Court.”

And as Zugibe, Apotheker and many of the graduates pointed out, “prevention program” isn’t synonymous with “easy.” The attendees are monitored (DWI offenders wear anklets that test their sobriety, the so-called “Lindsay Lohan” bracelet) and randomly drug-tested. They have to attend support groups and one-on-one counseling. Some of today’s graduates had setbacks, and ended up staying in longer.

More than one graduate made clear that, in many ways, a jail stint was less work than Drug Court. But, as one Drug Court grad said, “corrections facilities—they don’t correct anything.” Drug Court’s rewards can include a sober life, and a full one, making it worth the work.

“I was not a grown man,” one graduate said, reflecting on how he came into the program, “I was a nuisance . . . I was a menace to society.” He said now, “I’m back in college. I have a nice little GPA.”

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Thursday, January 28th, 2010 at 5:16 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

And we’re mad at the banks because …

Herb Pinder
January
27

When President Obama delivers his first State of the Union address tonight expect him to channel some of the populist anger that is so generously being heaped upon the banks. We wrote an advance on his speech today and we have video commentary from New Yorkers weighing in on Obama’s first year in office. The president doesn’t do the frothing-at-the-mouth, I’m-mad-as-hell thing very well. To get into the role, just as a method actor might, he should have tuned into the PBS Frontline that aired Tuesday on the banks.

“The Card Game” examined the consumer loan industry and how it … uh, has its way with consumers and Congress and federal regulators, with you know who getting stuck with the worst financial terms, the most usurious interest rates, and usually at the most inopportune times—say during a recession, when paychecks are shrinking or disappearing altogether.

Allow me this quick scorecard, re consumer protection over the many Congresses and White House administrations, as gleaned from the expose: the Democrats have been bad; the Republicans have been worse; the regulators are ineffectual and outgunned; Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner has a foul mouth—which he employs, though often in vain, to whip regulators into shape; and the consumer is an afterthought in all of this.

It should be enough to make a consumer and a president scream.

Posted by Herb Pinder on Wednesday, January 27th, 2010 at 10:00 am | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

A Haitian immigration how-to

Nancy Cutler
January
25

About 30 people crammed into U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel’s office in West Nyack this morning to discuss immigration changes for Haitians in light of the Jan. 12 earthquake, and how those changes are expected to impact Rockland and other areas in New York that have significant numbers of people of Haitian descent.

Engel brought U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Regional District Director Andrea Quarantillo to answer questions about the recently granted Temporary Protected Status, or TPS, for Haitians who are already in the U.S.  She gave a brief concise description of TPS, and answered questions and took suggestions from elected leaders and community leaders who run various nonprofits that aid the Haitian-American community.

But the last question underscored why we were there. As the meeting was wrapping up, Engel allowed one more question from a man amid the standing-room-only crowd in the small offices on West Nyack Road. He asked Quarantillo’s advice on how to get his two children out of Haiti, one who is a U.S. citizen but one who is not. “I don’t even know where they are,” he said after explaining their passport status and some of the government agencies he’s already worked with. “I heard a neighbor took them in.”

That’s what all the policy and procedure is supposed to accomplish — helping people find their loved ones, and reunite with them.

CIS, the State Department and  government agencies will continue to deal with these concerns locally. Last week, we reported about local officials readying for an uptick in immigration from Haiti. Rockland Department of Social Services Commissioner Susan Sherwood discussed the plans she’s been making with her staff, and the expectation that because of the strong Haitian-American community locally, specifically in Spring Valley, we could expect to see many Haitians fleeing the post-earthquake destruction to come here to join family. East Ramapo Schools Superintendent Ira Oustatcher said last week that one child who had left Haiti had already enrolled in his district. Today, a spokeswoman for Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee, D-Suffern, said six children had enrolled in that district. Nyack’s schools Superintendent Valencia Douglas, on behalf of other Rockland’s School Superintendents, has also expressed concern about preparing for children coming from Haiti. At today’s meeting, Rockland County Legislature Chairwoman Harriet Cornell sought further discussions on the impact of public schools from children coming here, a topic Engel acknowledged needed discussion.

But for today, the focus continues about who can come to the U.S. and how to get them there. Engel said he wants to make sure “no Haitian gets deported from this country. I can’t think of anything crueler than that.”

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Monday, January 25th, 2010 at 3:51 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

Haiti quake’s impact on schools

Nancy Cutler
January
20

Up to one third of East Ramapo school district’s students are of Haitian descent, estimates schools Superintendent Ira Oustatcher. His schools have experienced the heartbreak of the Haiti disaster. “We have a bus driver whose six family members died,” he said. And, he emotionally recalled, a father came to one school to seek help. He wanted to know how to tell his two children, who attend the school, that their mother had died.

With so many ties to the Caribbean nation, Oustatcher expected  that sooner or later, his office would see children of families fleeing the aftermath of the 7.0 magnitude quake enrolling in the East Ramapo schools.

That day has already come. Oustatcher said a student has been enrolled from Haiti.

Now, he says, districts like his, with large Haitian-American populations — in the Lower Hudson Valley that includes Nyack, North Rockland and White Plains — need to prepare for more. “We are going to start seeing families moving into the area,” he said this afternoon. “If I was a person who had family here … I’m packing up and leaving,” he said of those displaced, homeless, hurt by the disaster.

Oustatcher said that his and other communities need to start thinking about saving resources for those who come seeking refuge. “They don’t own winter coats — it’s Haiti,” he noted. Oustatcher said he was surprised that a student had come to his schools so soon. But many Haitian-American citizens, and those that hold green cards, do not necessarily need to go through the long immigration process to get here. “People go back and forth,” he said

“We’re having discussions of what that means for our district,” Oustacher said, and those discussions are taking place in other districts. “It will test our mettle,” he said.

Isn’t such a challenge, to educate all, in spite of obstacles, the mission of public schools? Oustatcher agreed. “It’s a great humanitarian moment,” he said.

Meanwhile, the East Ramapo district has rallied support for its students and their parents in the wake of the devastating Jan. 12 earthquake in Haiti. Counseling has been available throughout the school day, and even on weekends.  Many children have been seeking out support from staff during the school day.

The school district and students are engaged in fund-raising efforts, Oustatcher said, with each building holding drives. Other districts in the Lower Hudson Valley are mounting similar efforts.

One Ramapo High School sophmore, Nelie Exallis, is running a coin collection to help pay  $2,500 needed to prep a rescue pumper firetruck that is to be sent to Haiti. Other school districts are mounting charity efforts as well, many driven by the students.

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Wednesday, January 20th, 2010 at 4:40 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

TPS for Haitians in U.S.

Nancy Cutler
January
15

UPDATE:

aT 5:04 P.M., It was announced that President Obama and the Department of Homeland Security has granted Temporary Protected Status to Haitians in the United States whose visas have expired or may expire, and who were subject to deportation.

HERE WAS THE EARLIER POST, filed before the TPS announcement:

Last February, local Haitian-American activists rallied to urge the U.S. government to halt U.S. deportations of Haitians amid the devastation suffered in the Caribbean nation devastated by hurricanes, and already before that the poorest country in the Western Hemisphere. They were among those advocating for the Department of Homeland Security to grant eligible Haitian immigrants temporary protection status, or TPS.

Now, the push is on again to grant Haitian immigrants facing deportation TPS, a temporary immigration status granted by the United States to eligible nationals of certain countries who are unable to safely return to their home countries because of armed conflict, environmental disaster, or other extraordinary and temporary conditions.

Editorials supporting TPS appeared today in the Miami Herald and New York Times. U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel, D-Bronx, who pushed the Obama administration to grant TPS for Haitian immigrants last year, sent out a press release this evening encouraging TPS status for Haitians whose visas have expired or may expire, subjecting them to deportation.

He included a letter to the president, which reads:

Dear Mr. President:

On Tuesday, a devastating earthquake struck Haiti. This terrible event has killed thousands in the Port-au-Prince area and destroyed countless buildings.  We thank you for extending to the people of Haiti the deep condolences and unwavering support of the American people and directing your administration to respond with a swift, coordinated, and aggressive effort to save lives.

As members of Congress from New York, home to a very large Haitian diaspora community, we know that Haiti’s emergency needs are overwhelming.  Even with the death and casualty toll still unknown, the immediate need for food, medicines, water, emergency shelter, and equipment are obvious.  It is also clear that there will be an even greater need for a long-term commitment to rebuild the nation’s infrastructure, as well as educational, security, and economic assistance.  As the leader in our hemisphere and Haiti’s most important political partner, the U.S. should lead the way in supporting these efforts.

In the short term, we urgently request that you immediately direct the Secretary of Homeland Security to extend Temporary Protected Status (TPS) to Haitians currently in the United States. As you know, nationals of a country may be designated for TPS when that country has suffered an environmental disaster resulting in a substantial, temporary disruption of living conditions and it is temporarily unable to handle adequately the return of its nationals.  We believe that with Tuesday’s severe earthquake Haiti has more than exceeded the conditions for TPS designation and should be designated without delay.

Just over one year ago, Haiti was struck by severe flooding following hurricanes and storms, destroying much of the infrastructure of the country.  Before yesterday’s earthquake, Haiti was only beginning to recover from that disaster.  Given yesterday’s calamity, Haiti is completely incapable of handling an influx of thousands of additional people if they were sent back from the United States.

TPS has been routinely extended to nationals of various countries which have suffered natural disasters.  In the Western Hemisphere, alone, El Salvador, Nicaragua, and Honduras, are covered by TPS designations.  Given the devastation in Haiti, it would be incomprehensible if TPS was not extended to Haiti, as well.

It is our understanding that Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Assistant Secretary John Morton have halted all removals to Haiti for the time being in response to the devastation caused by yesterday’s earthquake. We urge you to take the next step and to designate Haitian nationals in the United States for TPS.

Again, as members of Congress from New York, the home of a very large Haitian diaspora community, we thank you for your assistance to the people of Haiti at this difficult time, and we look forward to hearing from you about Temporary Protected Status for Haitians in the United States.

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Friday, January 15th, 2010 at 5:17 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

Ties to Haiti

Nancy Cutler
January
13

The news of a devastating earthquake just outside Port-au-Prince has riveted the large and politically active Haitian-American community in Spring Valley.

UNTV video: A peacekeeper searches for survivors in the rubble of the destroyed MINUSTAH (United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti) headquarters in Port-au-Prince.

The catastrophe has touched so many here, which was obvious this morning at a press conference at Ramapo Town Hall.

Ramapo Town Supervisor Christopher St. Lawrence opened up the conference by expressing his concerns, in both English and Creole, for the nation that has such strong ties to our region. He had spent a solid 20 minutes calling up different elected officials and community leaders, most from the Haitian community. St. Lawrence has been to Haiti several times, and he and Spring Valley Trustee Joseph Desmaret, who was also in attendance, are chairman and vice chairman respectively, of the Haitian Solid Waste Authority (St. Lawrence is chairman of the Rockland Solid Waste Authority) and he spoke in great detail about the area where the earthquake hit, and about the nearby capital, Port-au-Prince, where he had been just months before.

The connection between Spring Valley and Haiti was underscored by the number of local officials of Haitian descent who spoke and referenced their own missing family members. Spring Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin was awaiting word on her husband, Ronald. Rose Leandre, the head of HACSO, a nonprofit, said she had just dropped her mom off at the airport Monday to return to Haiti and hadn’t heard from her. Another man mentioned his wife and son were missing. Two women stood, arms around another, fighting back tears. Another wept quietly during the press conference.  “Every single Haitian-American has family in Haiti,” said Spring Valley Trustee Demeza Delhomme.

Many in the group were determined to help coordinate relief efforts, even as they were so desperately seeking information about their loved ones. It demonstrated not only how a relatively new immigrant group remains linked to its homeland, but how Haiti’s long though often troubled legacy of democracy has fostered such deep community and political activism. Though the Haitian community in Rockland has grown tremendously in the last decade (estimates are that more than 30,000 people of Haitian decent live in the Spring Valley area), there are Haitian families that have lived here three, even four decades. Rockland County Legislator Jacques Michel, at his swearing-in ceremony in 2008, spoke of the Haitian freedom fighters who came to fight in the Revolutionary War, demonstrating Haiti’s long commitment to democracy.

Find out how to -How-you-can-help” target=”_blank”>here, and in tomorrow’s Journal News.

UNTV: A worker searches rubble of the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti.

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Wednesday, January 13th, 2010 at 4:15 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

Coming soon to a corner near you

Debra West
January
12

You’ve got opinions and we want to hear them.

Starting today we’ll be showing up in malls, diners and on street corners near you with a question of the day and a video camera.  It’s our updated, video version of the Inquiring Photographer. Don’t be shy; step up and tell us what you think and we’ll feature you on Lohud.com/opinionexchange.

Let’s get the conversation started!

Posted by Debra West on Tuesday, January 12th, 2010 at 12:39 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | Post a Comment »

Census seen as insensitive

Nancy Cutler
January
6

There’s always some controversy with the U.S. Census. This year’s no different. A review of the form shows that one category is relying on archaic language to help people classify their racial/ethnic heritage. People can check a box that describes their race as “Black African Am. or Negro.”

Some aren’t very happy, as reported today in the New York Daily News.

There’s a real risk in people finding a word like this offensive and junking the whole survey. Census information is very important, and communities benefit greatly from having all people who should be counted actually counted.

Ends up, though, the Census Bureau revived  “Negro” for the categories in 2008.

I perused old American Community Survey forms to see how that category had been listed before, and it seems that the word “Negro” was added in the 2008 and 2009 forms. So, it’s not really new language, but the first time it’s being used in the big count, so it’s gotten more attention.

Census Bureau spokesman Jack Martin told the Daily News that “Many older African-Americans identified themselves that way, and many still do. . . . Those who identify themselves as Negroes need to be included.” But New Yorkers they interviewed found the term either offensive or just plain outdated.

The Census takes place nationwide every decade, and is very important for distribution of federal funds, and representation in legislative branches of government (just look at the population drop in New York State from the 2000 Census that ended the congressional district of former Rep. Ben Gilman.) The word has been on earlier surveys in ACS communities, which provide year-by-year tabs for federal government use in spotting trends. Both Westchester and Rockland are ACS communities.

Some have complained that the 2010 Census survey is too limited in its racial and ethnic categories. They have said the Census doesn’t have a place for them to fit.

A May 2009 article by staff writer Leah Rae states:

Some West Indians are asking for a new question that would count those of Caribbean descent, akin to the Hispanic category. The Arab American Institute wants to add a broader question about ancestry to improve the count of Middle Easterners and others. Hispanics will likely respond to the race question as they have in the past, with many bypassing the listed options and choosing “some other race.”)

So, the federal government, it seems, is overdoing it for some, and falling short for others.

Posted by Nancy Cutler on Wednesday, January 6th, 2010 at 2:19 pm | | Email This Post Email This Post | 1 Comment »

Advertisement
About this blog
Welcome to the Opinion Exchange, the blog of the Community Conversation/Editorial Page desk of The Journal News and LoHud.com. Check here for regular roundups on the conversations online and in print that are driving the issues and stories in the Lower Hudson Valley. This is also your place for two-way conversation with the people behind the opinions at the TJN and LoHud.com. Help set and propel the Editorial BoardÕs agenda by steering us to the hot topics in your neighborhoods.

Subscribe

Daily Blog Email Updates


The Authors



Advertisement
Other recent entries

Links

Recent Comments


Advertisement


Recently Updated LoHud Blogs
Monthly Archives


Bad Behavior has blocked 492 access attempts in the last 7 days.