lohud.com

Sponsored by:

Opinion Exchange

A conversation with the Editorial Board

Comrade Moore . . .

September
26

This is the first weekend run for Michael Moore’s new documentary, Capitalism: A Love Story, his long-anticipated send up on Wall Street, the financial meltdown, the economy, and the not-so-free enterprise system. If you see it, feel free to share your view.

I  saw it Wednesday in the city. It was vintage MM—  lots of ironic humor, great cameos, the usual performance art stalkings of corporate bosses. (As you doubtless know by now, these scenes always end at corporate America’s revolving doors, at the unyielding stiff arm of security personnel, who are wiser these days, having seen this act in every other MM film.) Capitalism drew applause when the credits rolled, but I think it was Moore’s laziest work, especially given the target-rich environment.

In compelling fashion, MM strings together lots of disparate vignettes from history (especially from that unheralded “socialist” FDR—who knew?) and our modern-day troubles, to skewer an easy and flawed target—capitalism. That, however, is child’s play in the waning days of the Great Recession; who couldn’t do the same with one arm tied behind her back and a camcorder in the other?

Where Moore falls short is, in getting at the causes of our latest meltdown and how to prevent the next. Really, he doesn’t even try—at least not in a way that might advance anyone’s understanding of the problem. Instead, Moore pretty much goes with the mob mentality—the same one that almost doomed the bailout of the financial system (medicine without which the rest of the economy would have gone the way of Lehman Brothers); the same one that surely would have killed off the last of the auto workers for whom Moore has such uncritical affection and allegiance; the same one that might well doom health-care reform, the subject of another Moore treatment.

How lazy was Moore? He lets more than one member of Congress go on about secret and mysterious doings in Washington aimed at stealing our collective bacon, while ignoring a good bit of the public policy mistakes—committed IN THE OPEN—that most thoughtful analysts point to as catalysts for our misery. This work has already been done for Moore, but he opts for the vague conspiracy. The trouble with that: we can target and fix public policy mistakes—and we have a responsibility to do so—but when the focus is on mysterious conspiracies and unseen forces, well, that’s just an invitation to chase our tails. That lets us—and the policy-makers—off the hook.

If you really want to learn something about the economic mess, there’s a better alternative this weekend. Chicago Public Radio’s This American Life has a follow-up piece on last year’s The Giant Pool of Money, perhaps the best explanatory journalism on what went wrong. Here’s the link to Return to the Giant Pool of Money.

It might make you want to join the mob and go shopping for pitchforks.

This entry was posted on Saturday, September 26th, 2009 at 11:07 am by Herb Pinder. | Email This Post Email This Post

Advertisement

One Response to “Comrade Moore . . .”

  1. Sara M.

    That Pinder would even go to see a Michael Moore movie (and a poorly reviewed one at that), after the filmmaker has been roundly exposed as a factually-challenged huckster, says more about Pinder than he probably intended to share.

    Those of us who have been paying even a little attention long ago realized that the Journal News’ editorial page was in the hands of orthodox, doctrinaire leftists. Pinder’s blog entry validates that, including that for Pinder, the movie was “long-anticipated” (ha!) and his use of scare quotes on “socialist” in the context of FDR. The terms that should have been in scare quotes include “documentary” and “performance art.”

Leave a Reply

Advertisement
About this blog
Welcome to the Opinion Exchange, the blog of the Community Conversation/Editorial Page desk of The Journal News and LoHud.com. Check here for regular roundups on the conversations online and in print that are driving the issues and stories in the Lower Hudson Valley. This is also your place for two-way conversation with the people behind the opinions at the TJN and LoHud.com. Help set and propel the Editorial BoardÕs agenda by steering us to the hot topics in your neighborhoods.

Subscribe

Daily Blog Email Updates


The Authors



Advertisement
Other recent entries

Links

Recent Comments


Advertisement


Recently Updated LoHud Blogs
Monthly Archives


Bad Behavior has blocked 635 access attempts in the last 7 days.